Rizendoekie: A true reddit steak would be filled with salt and spite.
seamore555: Gave this a shot but I replaced the soy sauce with ketchup and the whiskey with mustard.
Also, swapped out the steak for hot dogs (I’m allergic to steak) and served it on a white processed bun.
It was amazing! Only cried twice while eating it alone on my bed in a bachelor apartment.
KrazieKanuck: Who else was worried he was going to turn it inside out???
DaveDiggler6590: I mean it looks delicious, but I wouldn’t marinade good steak like that…
MimonFishbaum: Looks beautiful but the soy sauce Jack Daniels marinade made me gag a bit.
Emmafabb: Why doesn’t the plastic bag melt?
Is this a dumb question?
mrboombastic123: Credit where it’s due, that looks excellent inside and out. Would have liked to see some browning on that fat too if I’m being super critical, but this was a great job.
Someone else mentioned resting the steak, but do you rest with sous vide? Haven’t used one before.
Tamrowski: It’s funny how butt hurt a lot of people are for this guy doing something fun.
Oh you ruined the cow.
Disrespectful.
You don’t do that.
This person paid for the shit, they can make a funny bit of content out of it if they want. Nobody is making you cook reddit steak.
C0R4x: What type of sous vide plate is this?
I thought about a diy version similar to this (hot plate with temperature probe instead of an immersion water heater), but never got around to actually doing it. Does it work well?
Edit: /u/Chris_Winkler, this question was meant for you 😉
meateater123: When I saw reddit steak I thought this would be a joke and it’d just be a totally uncooked piece of steak put on a plate
LERinsanity: Pan-searing in oil over butter? I think butter adds such a rich flavour
ChipsHandon12: You forgot to turn the steak inside out after
fatal965: When I saw reddit steak I thought it would just be a gif of the guy patting it dry then serving it on a plate completely raw cause anything else “is a fucking embarrassment”
totalbasterd: what is that hot plate hob/cooker thing?
Sylvester_Scott: What’s the reason for patting it dry?
Dinojeezus: Marinade is what you MARINATE in for two hours.
Looks tasty, though. Now I’m craving a steak.
sargizard: You don’t marinade a wagyu steak
socsa: Marinading a Ribeye seems a bit like using lube for a blowjob. It’s probably not hurting anything, but there’s really no purpose.
jackherer: ITT: no one knows the difference between marinate and marinade
TaruNukes: Lotta people gatekeeping on how to make a steak here. If it’s good, that’s all that matters
vikingpride11: I’m here for steak drama
charface1: I would have preferred a milk steak, boiled over hard.
SugarBagels: I’ll take my big green egg experience so I can be outside